Review & Swatches: Jesse’s Girl Eye Shadow Compact in “Brown Eyed Girl”

Jesse’s Girl Eye Shadow Compact in Brown Eyed Girl

Availability: Jesse’s Girl Online & Rite Aid
Price: $3.99

Jesse’s Girl Cosmetics sells 4 different 9-pan eye shadow palettes. Brown Eyed Girl is reviewed, here.


Free shipping for orders of $50 or more

Packaging: 8.75/10

This palettes comes in a black, plastic compact with a snap-shut lid and a narrow window on the lid to let you preview the colors inside.

The packaging feels a little cheap and the pans are small, so some eye shadow brushes won’t fit in them.

Quality: 8.25/10

These shadows have decent pigmentation. The palette contains mostly warm-toned browns, so if you look best with cool-toned colors, this isn’t the palette for you.

All of the colors are shimmery, which doesn’t make it easy to do a full look with just this palette. The formula is smooth, but on the powdery side.

Ease of Use: 8.75/10

You get decent color pay-off without needing to layer. Just be careful with fall-out since the shadows are powdery.

Price: 9/10

For $3.99, you get 9 decently-formulated colors. I think Wet-n-Wild’s palettes are a little better, overall, but Jesse’s Girl palettes contain more colors.

Final Grade

85.5/100

Jesse’s Girl Eye Shadow Compact in Brown Eyed Girl

Jesse’s Girl Eye Shadow Compact in Brown Eyed Girl

Jesse’s Girl Eye Shadow Compact in Brown Eyed Girl

Jesse’s Girl Eye Shadow Compact in Brown Eyed Girl Swatches

Jesse’s Girl Eye Shadow Compact in Brown Eyed Girl Swatches

Jesse’s Girl Eye Shadow Compact in Brown Eyed Girl Swatches


Natural Beauty Spring 2012 Collection

This entry was posted in B, Brands, Grades, Jesse's Girl, Reviews, Swatches and tagged , , , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

5 Responses to Review & Swatches: Jesse’s Girl Eye Shadow Compact in “Brown Eyed Girl”

  1. Lisa B. says:

    There’s another of those rusty reds…these look VERY warm…there’s one that looks like MAC Me Over Outre (the mustardy colored one). Can you use these, or are they too warm for you?

  2. How are they when wet? Are they pigmented?

  3. Eva says:

    pretty shades!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *