Review & Swatches: Shop MAC / Cook MAC Lipsticks

Shop MAC / Cook MAC Lipsticks

Availability: MAC Stores & Online
Price: $14.50

Company’s Description

Spring lips dish it up! With our shop-til-you-drop shades and the collection’s colourful and fun packaging these shades stay fashionable long after check-out.

This review is for the 4 new lipstick colors releasing with MAC’s upcoming Shop MAC / Cook MAC Collection. This post includes photographs and swatches of the following colors:

  • Naughty Saute (Cremesheen): Bright pepto pink
  • Watch Me Simmer (Amplified): Bright pink-orange
  • Quick Sizzle (Matte): Bright pink
  • Dish It Up (Lustre): Berry pink

Innocence, Beware! and Runaway Red are re-promoted with this collection also.

Big Savings at DermStore

Packaging: 9/10

These lipsticks come in standard MAC packaging. The tubes are made of plastic and can easily be taken on-the-go. The outer box packaging has a retro, throw-back design.

Quality: 9.25/10

Naughty Saute is a semi-transparent bubblegum pink with a sheen finish. The formula, surprisingly, was a bit stiff and took a couple of swipes over the skin to warm up the product before the color transferred onto the lips.

Watch Me Simmer is vibrant coral with the intense, dense finish expected of the Amplified formula. It applied smoothly and opaquely.

Quick Sizzle is a deep pink magenta. Even though it’s a matte formula, it’s not stiff or dry and transfers onto the skin pretty easily, leaving an opaque and bold finish. The surface does have a sheen to it–similar to an Amplified formula–so I wouldn’t classify the finish as strictly “matte.” This color is very similar to Pink Pigeon from MAC’s Iris Apfel collection, so if you already have Pink Pigeon, there’s no need to buy Quick Sizzle. Quick Sizzle is ever-so-slightly more opaque and deep in hue, but the differences are minimal.

Dish It Up is a translucent bougainvillea color with a glossy finish. Because it’s a Lustre formula, the surface can look a bit uneven but can be smoothed out with some layering.

Overall, this is a strong set of lipstick colors. My top criticism is that Naughty Saute is stiffer than ideal. Otherwise, these lipsticks have good pigmentation and strong finishes. FYI, Watch Me Simmer and (particularly) Quick Sizzle will stain your skin.

Ease of Use: 9/10

Naughty Saute requires warming up before use. The other 3 colors transfer easily. You should apply Quick Sizzle and Watch Me Simmer slowly or with a lip brush, since the bright colors will magnify any mistakes you make.

Price: 9/10

These are the same size (3 g) as regular MAC lipsticks and cost $14.50 each.

Final Grade


Shop MAC / Cook MAC Lipstick Box Packaging

Shop MAC / Cook MAC Lipsticks

Shop MAC / Cook MAC Lipstick Swatches

Shop MAC / Cook MAC Lipstick in Naughty Saute

Shop MAC / Cook MAC Lipstick in Naughty Saute Swatch Applied

Shop MAC / Cook MAC Watch Me Lipstick in Watch Me Simmer

Shop MAC / Cook MAC Watch Me Lipstick in Watch Me Simmer Swatch Applied

Shop MAC / Cook MAC Lipstick in Dish It Up

Shop MAC / Cook MAC Lipstick in Dish It Up Swatch Applied

Shop MAC / Cook MAC Lipstick in Quick Sizzle

Shop MAC / Cook MAC Lipstick in Quick Sizzle Swatch Applied

Gift with Purchase at DermStore
This entry was posted in A, Brands, Collections, Grades, MAC, Reviews, Swatches and tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

12 Responses to Review & Swatches: Shop MAC / Cook MAC Lipsticks

  1. sthobbie says:

    Thanks so much for the lipswatchs… I can’t choose I want all four of them =)

  2. Sthobbie says:

    Love the lip swatches! Too bad the lovely packaging of the items is only on the carton

  3. Sarah L. says:

    These lipsticks are such pretty shades! I want all of them, haha- the colours and the finish and feel of them are of higher qualities so yay! Definitely will check them out 😀


  4. Bellachique says:

    I can’t wait for this collection to come out, all the lipsticks look just gorgeous!

  5. Vanessa says:

    Thank you so much for these and for the details. Does quick sizzle resemble any of the perm shades as well? Also,does watch me simmer look like a more augmented version of flamingo? I’ve heard this before,and really hope so. Thanks for your fab swatches.

  6. KIA says:

    i love you!!! thanks so much for the swatches!

  7. Leslie says:

    You’re awesome for getting these up so fast! I’ve been waiting for swatches for days and I think you’re the first. 😀

  8. surabhi lal says:

    Lovely swatches I think I will buy watch me simmer 🙂

  9. T says:

    Thanks so much for the pictures and swatches! I think you may have Quick Sizzle and Dish it Up mislabeled though, I know Dish it Up is supposed to be the lustre, so I think it’d be the more sheer one. I could be wrong though 🙂

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *