Review & Swatches: Tarte Eye Candy Amazonian Clay Shadow Stick Collection

Tarte Eye Candy Amazonian Clay Shadow Stick Collection

Availability: Tarte Online
Price: $29.50

Company’s Description

This set of six silky-smooth and waterproof shadows last all day and can take you from day to night! More than meets the eye, these smart shadow sticks neutralize and balance lids for smooth application and budge-proof wear. Oily lids? Amazonian clay minimizes oil in and around pores to balance skin and keep product in place. Dry lids? This nourishing clay hydrates skin naturally to restore moisture and keep product from flaking off. Whether your lids are oily or dry, Amazonian clay ensures silky-smooth application, and extended waterproof wear.

This review is for Tarte’s limited-edition Eye Candy Amazonian Clay Shadow Stick Collection. This set includes 6 shades: Charcoal, Champagne, Bronze, Moss, Taupe, and Plum.

Charcoal is a dark steel grey with blue-silver shimmer. Champagne is a medium champagne color with a sheen finish. Bronze is a chocolate brown with silver glitters. Moss is a medium khaki green with a sheen finish. Taupe is, unlike its name, a light sepia color with a golden sheen finish. Plum is a medium purple with an almost-matte finish.

If you would like to see live swatches, there is a video overview available.

tarte cosmetics

Packaging: 9/10

These shadows come in plastic pencil-shaped tubes that twist to reveal more product. The caps snap on tightly and securely.

Quality: 9.8/10

All of the colors are intensely pigmented and have sheen or glittery finishes, with Plum being the least shimmery.

The formula is unbelievably creamy, applying evenly and smoothly.

The shadow also lives up to Tarte’s claims. These are, by all practical accounts, waterproof. As you can see in the last photo, below, the product stays put, even after trying to rub it off with a makeup wipe. The formula is also pretty much crease-proof once you let it set, which takes 1-2 minutes.

Ease of Use: 9.8/10

These glide on effortlessly without any tugging at the skin. You don’t even need to layer the product because the color payoff is great with only a single swipe.

The only negative in using this product is the difficulty you’ll encounter removing it. Use an oil-based makeup remover to reduce the need for scrubbing at the skin on your lids.

Price: 10/10

For $29.50, you get 6 shadow sticks, each containing 1.64 grams (0.05 ounces) of product. MAC’s Shadesticks cost $17.50 and each contain 1.5 grams (0.05 ounces) of product. Given that you get 6-times more product with the Eye Candy collection, you get a tremendous value.

Final Grade


Tarte Eye Candy Amazonian Clay Shadow Stick Collection

Tarte Eye Candy Amazonian Clay Shadow Stick Collection

Tarte Eye Candy Amazonian Clay Shadow Stick Collection Swatches: Charcoal, Champagne, Bronze, Moss, Taupe, Plum

Swatches After Trying to Remove with Makeup Wipe

receive free shipping on orders of $40+ at tarte cosmetics

This entry was posted in A, Brands, Grades, Reviews, Swatches, Tarte and tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

7 Responses to Review & Swatches: Tarte Eye Candy Amazonian Clay Shadow Stick Collection

  1. Lisa B. says:

    Ooh nice…MAC Shadesticks still tend to fade and smear a little on me…

  2. Gift Princess says:

    Seriously wicked! I love the combination of colors, work-friendly and for parties too!

  3. Sthobbie says:

    This is a steal, it is so frustrating sometimes to see great brands like tarte have good value packed in the US that we can’t get in Europe, one more reason to travel

  4. Jennifer says:

    These look so tempting!!! I would really consider buying these… But I’m quite short on money right now so I want to make the smartest purchase I possibly can. Thank you for this review! I watched the video and LOVED it! You really do make the best swatches ever! xoxo.

  5. Theresa says:

    I have these and LOVE them! They are so waterproof they stay on my waterline for 6+ hours! And the individual shades are 25 dolloars each at Sephora, so this is an amazing deal. 🙂

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *